The Fordham Law Forum on Law, Culture & Society has moved!

Please visit www.fordhamlawandculture.org

Courtrooms as TV Entertainment Pictures

Courtrooms as TV Entertainment

Binding Arbitration and Small Claims

The audience that attended the Forum: Courtrooms as TV Entertainment, learned many things on the night when we hosted Judges Marilyn Milian and Alex Ferrer. First, as an incentive for parties to opt out of small claims court and to enter the legal arena of reality TV, the producers agree to pay the cost of the losing side--meaning that whatever monetary judgment is handed down, the defendant will not be responsible for paying it. The producers of the show will pay the damage award. Second, these TV courtrooms scour the country for interesting, sometimes salacious cases that are scheduled to be heard in small claims court. Then they determine whether the parties to the action, along with their claims, would make for engaging, compelling television. The result is binding arbitration--whatever happens on television in resolving the case, whatever judgment the judges reach, is final. There is no appeal. But would this formula work with more complex cases, those that are not heard in small claims court? And why is it that people choose to opt out of the essential privacy of a state court proceeding in order to be humiliated in front of a national television audience?

Emotion in the Courtroom

We screened a few clips of our judges, sitting on the bench, ruling on cases, and in some instances, functioning m0re like real people with actual emotions than cold jurists. In fact, in one clip we saw Judge Milian tearfully telling a plaintiff that it was time for him to get on with his life. In another clip, Judge Ferrer had completely disarmed a plaintiff by engaging in a conversation that seemed too personal and would have been regarded as undignified if not altogether inappropriate in a more conventional court of law. Both of our guests, however, agreed that such displays of human behavior humanized the legal experience for most people, rather than having the law come across as cold, unfeeling, and remote from basic human emotions. Bringing judges down from their pedestals of emotional indifference builds greater trust with those who appear before them and provides citizens with a stronger connection to justice and a greater sense that they have actually received a true hearing and their day in court. As Judge Milian said: "The people love us. What they don't love are the judges who have treated them badly and shown them no respect."

Judging or Entertaining?

A fair amount of the lively discussion was devoted to the question: If the courtroom cases are serious, and they are intended to impart important moral lessons about the differences between right and wrong, then should it matter who the plaintiffs and defendants are, and how they, and their claims, come across on the TV screen? Both of our judges were quick to point out that their producers recruit interesting cases and the people attached to them. These courtrooms shows may be authentic demonstrations of dispute resolution, but they also have the burden to hold the attention of TV audiences, who might otherwise switch to a soap opera, a cable movie, or even worse, a competing courtroom TV show. There is always the power and prerogative of the remote control. But this invites the question: Aren't all disputes interesting in some way, or is it that what's most important are the personalities behind the disputes. Judges respond to people as people; they don't merely, and coldly, only deal with the legal claim as a matter of law, divorced of the emotion that is an indispensable part of the cases before them.

Courtrooms as TV Entertainment: Charasmatic Courtroom Jurists

Judge Marilyn Milian, from "The People's Court, and Judge Alex Ferrer, from "Judge Alex," were fantastic guests of the Forum. Everyone in the audience was treated to two articulate, telegenic, passionate, and hilarious jurists. Indeed, while their syndicated television shows are wildly successful, I think they both agreed that when not filming their TV shows they should consider taking their act, as a pair of TV judges, on the road. Even a sitcom would work. They are obvious friends who finish each other's sentences and almost know what the other is about to say. It was funny when Judge Milian, at one point, invoked Lucy at the chocolate factory, because the good judge is very much cut from the same cloth as the charismatic Lucy Arnez/Ball, which is ironic, since both Milian and Ferrer are Cuban Americans, as was Desi Arnez. The rapport and chemistry of our TV judges, and their ease in front of a live audience, was interesting to observe, because unlike our past Forum guests, these judges are on television, so they have a burden to entertain in front of the camera, whereas our prior guests were mostly writers whose words are read by others and who live mostly on the page.

Forum Guest: Judge Marilyn Milian

Judge Marilyn Milian, the first Latina Judge to host a nationally syndicated television court show, presides over the courtroom that launched the entire court show genre. Milian brings to the bench extensive experience including ten years as a prosecutor, under former Attorney General Janet Reno, and seven years as a judge presiding over everything from small claims cases to death penalty litigation.

People's Court is a one-hour nationally syndicated reality based court show featuring real litigants, real cases and real justice. People's Court draws on ordinary people who have filed grievances in civil court and have opted to have their cases heard and mediated by Judge Milian.

Forum Guest: Judge Alex Ferrer

Former police officer, attorney and Florida Circuit Court Judge Alex E. Ferrer hosts “Judge Alex,” daytime’s number one new first-run strip for the 2005-06 season from Twentieth Television. Judge Alex is the only television judge with extensive police, legal and judicial experience, presiding over a wide array of cases, resolving complicated issues with his straight forward approach and cogent rulings.

Most recently, Judge Alex served as the Associate Administrative Judge of the Criminal Division of Florida’s Eleventh Judicial Circuit, which services Miami-Dade County, the largest trial court in the state and fourth largest in the United States.

Save The Date! April 25th Forum Event With Judge Marilyn Milian and Judge Alex Ferrer!

The Forum on Law, Culture, and Society is excited to announce our next Forum Event. Seating for this event is limited, please use this link to register!
Courtrooms as TV Entertainment: A Conversation with Judge Marilyn Milian from "The People's Court," and Judge Alex Ferrer of "Judge Alex."
Date(s): 04.25.07 Wed
Time: 8:00 p.m.
Location: One Time Warner Center
Sponsor: Forum on Law, Culture, & Society. With support from Time Warner and Entwistle & Cappucci LLP.

Program Description:
Judge Marilyn Milian of "The People's Court" and Judge Alex Ferrer of "Judge Alex" headline the Fordham Law School Forum on Law, Culture & Society's April 25 program, Courtrooms as TV Entertainment.

The conversation will tune in to the phenomenon of daytime TV courtrooms: how they affect our culture and what they say about those judged- and those transfixed- by TV judgments.

In conversation with Thane Rosenbaum, the Forum's Director, and in viewing some clips from their shows, the judges will weigh in on why daytime TV courtrooms reflect the public's fascination with the legal system. Why do viewing audiences revel in the lives of ordinary people fighting over ordinary things? Is it that we seek the daily moral lesson, immediacy, and finality that comes from watching a court case resolve itself before the next commercial break? Are participants seeking their 15 minutes of fame, or are they perhaps longing for their private misdeeds and pain to be aired, and cleansed, by the American public?

Fordham Law School's Forum on Law, Culture, & Society is made possible through the generous support of Time Warner and Entwistle & Cappucci LLP.

After each Forum, the conversation continues in cyberspace via pod-casting and an interactive blog at: fordhamlawandculture.blogspot.com, also accessible via www.fordhamlawandculture.org.